The huge increase of the balancing and conversion neutrality charge in particular by NCG is still causing a bad mood and leading to discussions among market participants. In the last edition, ener|gate Gasmarkt reported about the anger among trading companies about the NCG conversion neutrality charge. Gaspool and NCG have now published documents with an explanation of the calculation. More will be reported about this later. First, something about the latest discussions on the balancing neutrality charge and an exchange of letters. In the following, we will focus on NCG. The discussion is currently focused on this market area operator (MAO) as the changes of the neutrality charges were extraordinarily high, and, in particular, much higher than expected.
Stay up to date with the free Gasmarkt-Newsletter! We will inform you about new issues by e-mail and give you an insight into the contents.
- Issue title:
Balancing and conversion neutrality charge
- Publication date:
- In this issue:
In this edition, you will find a rather long box with the latest developments around “renewable” gas and renewable hydrogen. The effort the industry is making to promote the topic is remarkable. I hesitated to include the Gasunie Deutschland, Thyssengas and TenneT project ELEMENT EINS in the box. Shouldn‘t the project be appreciated more prominently? Ultimately, I thought it fits in nicely with the other events and that it does not dilute its significance. The project nicely demonstrates one of the most urgent questions for the fast further development of the power-to-gas (PtG or P2G) technology: Is it justified to make such plants part of the regulated asset base? BNetzA has a very clear answer: No! There are good reasons for the rejection by the authority, because network operators may become traders for green methane/hydrogen. However, even market participants that in principal share the BNetzA’s negative assessment believe that it makes sense to have a closer look at the regulatory framework. I attended an event (under Chatham House Rules), in which senior managers of the power transmission operators participated as well. Two messages impressed me: First, P2G will most likely be needed sooner than later to support the power networks, as the further extension of the power grid will become more and more difficult due to public resistance. Second, it makes sense to analyse whether it might be a way forward to separate ownership and operations. Network operators may own PtG plants, but operations might be carried out by third parties. Most likely, it is not the regulator alone who can be made responsible for an adequate framework for P2G plants, but an adjustment of the legal framework might be necessary. Serious discussions about what is needed and what the alternatives are should start very soon.
At the end of August and in September, both MAOs published the calculation basis respectively for the conversion fee and the conversion neutrality charge. Both documents offer much more to read than the four pages published by the two MAOs on the balancing neutrality charges. Unfortunately, the two reports do not have an identical structure and proceeding. Therefore, a comparison is not directly possible for each topic. The NCG report is more elaborate.
Key Account Manager
Tel: +49 201 1022-529
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the energate Gasmarkt?
The energate Gasmarkt provides specialists and executives in the gas industry with up-to-date information and background information on the German and international gas market. The medium expertly explains the most important developments in the fields of market, law, politics and business. In addition, the energate Gasmarkt offers insider information such as market rumors and personal details.
2. What is the energate Jahresreport Gas?
The energate Jahresreport Gas traces the most important market developments of the year and provides a well-founded outlook for the coming months. Gas expert and insider Dr. Heiko Lohmann analyzes relevant events in politics, law and regulation as well as on generation, infrastructure and trade. In addition, the report provides information on changes in the corporate landscape and tracks price developments in market reports. Top decision-makers from the industry use the Jahresreport Gas as a compact chronicle of the year and to assess future market developments.
3. How often are these publications released and in which formats are they available?
The energate Gasmarkt is published monthly. Subscribers will receive the energate Gasmarkt as a print and PDF version in German and English. The Jahresreport Gas is published annually (beginning of December).
4. Can I purchase individual issues of the energate Gasmarkt?
Yes, you can purchase individual isses as print or PDF version. Payment options include purchase on account, credit card or PayPal.
5. How much is a subscription of the energate Gasmarkt and how much does the Jahresreport cost?
A subscription to the energate Gasmarkt (single licence) costs 110,- Euro/month (plus VAT). An edition of the Jahresreport Gas costs regularly 390,- euro (plus VAT). Special conditions apply to energate messenger+ subscribers.
6. Are there any special conditions if several employees in a company would like to receive the Gasmarkt?
With several Gasmarkt recipients in one company, the price of the second and all other licenses is reduced significantly. We are happy to make you a fair offer for team or corporate licenses!
7. What benefits do I get by registering?
After the free registration on this page, you will receive an e-mail on the day of publication with an overview of the contents of the current issue.